Strategy Consulting vs. Management Consulting Differences

Author: Taylor Warfield, Former Bain Manager and Interviewer


Strategy consulting vs. management consulting


Strategy consulting vs. management consulting are terms you'll hear constantly during your consulting job search. Many people use them interchangeably, but they're not quite the same thing. 

 

Understanding the difference matters because it affects which firms you target, what kind of work you'll do, and where your career goes after consulting.

 

Here's the short answer: strategy consulting is a specialized type of management consulting. All strategy consultants are management consultants, but not all management consultants do strategy work. 

 

Strategy focuses on "what should we do?" while broader management consulting tackles "how do we do it?" This article breaks down exactly what each type involves, which firms do what, and how to decide which path fits your goals.

 

But first, a quick heads up:

 

To land either job, you’ll have to pass consulting case interviews, which can take months to learn on your own.

 

If you’re looking for a step-by-step shortcut to learn case interviews quickly, enroll in my case interview course and save yourself 100+ hours. 82% of my students land consulting offers (8x the industry average).

 

What Is Management Consulting?

 

Management consulting is the broad category that covers almost all business advisory work. When companies face problems they can't solve internally, they hire management consultants to help.

 

These problems span every part of a business:

 

  • Operations
  • Technology
  • Human resources
  • Finance
  • Marketing
  • Supply chain
  • Organizational structure. 

 

If it affects how a company runs, management consultants work on it.

 

Companies hire management consultants for a few key reasons. 

 

First, consultants bring specialized expertise that doesn't exist in-house. Second, they offer an outside perspective free from internal politics. Third, they provide flexible resources for projects that don't justify permanent hires. Fourth, they can move faster than internal teams bogged down by day-to-day responsibilities.

 

The "Big Four" accounting firms (Deloitte, PwC, EY, KPMG) have massive management consulting practices. So do technology-focused firms like Accenture and IBM. These firms handle everything from implementing new software systems to redesigning organizational structures to improving manufacturing processes.

 

Management consulting is a huge industry. It generates over $300 billion in global revenue annually and employs hundreds of thousands of consultants worldwide.

 

What Is Strategy Consulting?

 

Strategy consulting sits at the top of the consulting pyramid. It focuses on the biggest, most important questions a company faces. 

 

  • Should we enter this new market?
  • Should we acquire this competitor?
  • How do we respond to a disruptive threat?
  • Where should we invest for growth over the next five years?

 

These are "what" questions, not "how" questions. Strategy consultants help CEOs and boards decide what direction to take the company. They don't typically stick around to implement those decisions.

 

The clients are almost always C-suite executives, board members, or private equity partners. The stakes are enormous. A wrong strategic decision can cost billions of dollars or sink an entire company. That's why strategy consulting commands premium fees and attracts top talent.

 

McKinsey, BCG, and Bain (often called "MBB") are the most prestigious strategy consulting firms. They built their reputations on high-level strategic advice to Fortune 500 companies and governments. Other well-known strategy firms include Kearney, Roland Berger, Strategy&, L.E.K. Consulting, and Oliver Wyman.

 

Strategy consulting is considered the most prestigious branch of consulting. It's also the most competitive to break into. These firms recruit heavily from top MBA programs and elite undergraduate universities, and their interview processes are notoriously rigorous.

 

Key Differences Between Strategy and Management Consulting

 

The differences between strategy and management consulting show up in almost every aspect of the work. Here's how they compare across the dimensions that matter most.

 

Scope of Work

 

Strategy consultants tackle big-picture questions about company direction.

 

  • Should we expand internationally?
  • What business should we be in five years from now?
  • How do we respond to a new competitor?

 

Management consultants handle the execution side. 

 

  • How do we integrate this acquisition?
  • How do we cut costs in our supply chain?
  • How do we implement this new technology platform?

 

Client Level

 

Strategy consultants work primarily with CEOs, CFOs, board members, and private equity partners. These are the people who make major strategic decisions.

 

Management consultants often work with middle and senior management. They might partner with a VP of Operations to redesign a manufacturing process or work with an IT director on a systems implementation.

 

Project Length

 

Strategy projects tend to be shorter and more intense. A typical strategy engagement lasts 4 to 12 weeks. You're answering a specific strategic question, then moving on.

 

Management consulting projects often run much longer. An implementation project might last 6 months to 2 years. You're not just recommending a solution; you're making sure it actually works.

 

Level of Ambiguity

 

Strategy work operates in high uncertainty. You're often exploring questions that have no clear answer. For example: should this consumer goods company enter the plant-based meat market? Nobody knows for sure. 

 

You gather data, build models, stress-test assumptions, and make your best recommendation.

 

Management consulting tends to have more defined problems. The client knows they need to cut costs or implement a new system. The question is how to do it well.

 

Skills Emphasized

 

Strategy consulting places heavy emphasis on structured problem solving, quantitative analysis, and synthesizing ambiguous information into clear recommendations. You need to frame problems crisply and communicate with senior executives.

 

Management consulting also requires analytical skills, but often emphasizes project management, stakeholder alignment, change management, and technical expertise in specific domains.

 

Team Structure

 

Strategy teams are typically small. A project might have 3 to 5 consultants working intensively together.

 

Management consulting projects can involve much larger teams, sometimes dozens of consultants across multiple workstreams. The scale matches the scope of implementation work.

 

Example Projects for Each Type

 

Seeing real project examples makes the distinction clearer. Here's what consultants in each type actually work on.

 

Strategy Consulting Projects

 

  • A consumer goods company wants to know whether to acquire a competitor. The strategy team analyzes market dynamics, assesses synergies, models different purchase prices, and recommends whether to proceed

  • A private equity firm is considering buying a healthcare services business. Consultants conduct commercial due diligence to assess whether the investment thesis holds up

  • A bank faces disruption from fintech startups. The strategy team develops a five-year digital transformation roadmap and recommends which capabilities to build versus buy versus partner

  • A government wants to attract more foreign investment. Consultants benchmark against other countries, identify target sectors, and design incentive programs

  • A retailer's growth has stalled. The strategy team identifies new customer segments to target, new product categories to enter, and new geographic markets to expand into

 

Management Consulting Projects

 

  • A manufacturer needs to reduce costs by 15%. Consultants analyze operations, identify efficiency improvements, redesign processes, and work with plant managers to implement changes

  • A hospital system is implementing a new electronic health records system. The consulting team manages the rollout, trains staff, and troubleshoots issues

  • Two companies have merged and need to combine their organizations. Consultants design the new structure, plan the integration, and help manage the transition

  • A company wants to improve its cybersecurity posture. Consultants assess vulnerabilities, recommend solutions, and help implement new security protocols

  • An insurance company needs to modernize its claims processing. The consulting team redesigns workflows, selects technology vendors, and oversees implementation

 

One important note: most consultants work on both types of projects throughout their careers. Even at strategy-focused firms like McKinsey, you might do implementation work. And Big Four consultants sometimes get staffed on strategic projects.

Top Strategy and Management Consulting Firms

 

Knowing which firms focus on which type of work helps you target your applications. Here's how the major players break down.

 

Strategy-Focused Firms

 

McKinsey, BCG, and Bain are the "MBB" firms that dominate strategy consulting. They're the most prestigious and most selective.

 

Other respected strategy firms include:

 

  • Kearney (formerly A.T. Kearney)
  • Roland Berger
  • Strategy& (PwC's strategy arm)
  • L.E.K. Consulting
  • Oliver Wyman
  • OC&C Strategy Consultants
  • Simon-Kucher & Partners

 

These firms do primarily strategic work, though most have expanded into implementation and specialty areas.

 

Broader Management Consulting Firms

 

The Big Four (Deloitte, PwC, EY, KPMG) have huge consulting practices that span strategy through implementation. These firms do some strategy work, but they're better known for technology consulting, risk advisory, operations improvement, and implementation.

 

The Big Four have been acquiring strategy boutiques and building dedicated strategy practices. Deloitte bought Monitor Group. PwC acquired Booz & Company (now Strategy&). These strategy arms operate somewhat independently and focus on high-level strategic work.

 

So, you can do strategy consulting at a Big Four firm, but you need to target their strategy practice specifically.

 

Salary Comparison

 

Compensation differs significantly between strategy firms and broader management consulting firms. Strategy consulting generally pays more, especially at the top firms.

 

Entry-Level Compensation

 

At MBB firms, a post-MBA consultant earns a base salary of approximately $200,000, plus a signing bonus of $25,000 to $35,000, plus a performance bonus that can add another $40,000 to $50,000. Total first-year compensation often exceeds $250,000.

 

At Big Four consulting practices, post-MBA hires typically start at $150,000 to $175,000 base salary, with smaller bonuses. Total first-year compensation usually falls in the $175,000 to $210,000 range.

 

Undergraduate hires see similar gaps. MBB firms pay $110,000 to $120,000 base salary plus bonuses for entry-level analysts. Big Four consulting roles start closer to $85,000 to $100,000.

 

Senior-Level Compensation

 

The gap widens at senior levels. An MBB partner can earn $1 million to $5 million or more annually. Partners at Big Four consulting practices typically earn $500,000 to $2 million. The very top MBB partners earn eight figures.

 

These numbers change frequently, so check current salary data when you're evaluating offers. But the pattern holds: strategy consulting at top firms pays a premium over broader management consulting.

 

Work-Life Balance and Hours

 

Neither type of consulting is known for work-life balance, but there are differences worth understanding.

 

Strategy Consulting Hours

 

Strategy projects run fast. Clients pay premium fees and expect rapid answers. Expect 55- to 70-hour weeks on average, with some weeks pushing higher. The intensity varies by project and firm. Some MBB offices have reputations for being more demanding than others.

 

One advantage of strategy work: projects are shorter. You might have an intense 8-week sprint, then get a week or two of lighter work before the next project. The peaks are high, but there are periods of downtime.

 

Management Consulting Hours

 

Hours vary more widely in management consulting. Implementation projects can be demanding, but they often run at a steadier pace than strategy sprints.

 

Expect 50 to 65 hours per week at most Big Four and Accenture roles, though this depends heavily on the specific practice and project.

 

Technology implementation projects sometimes allow more predictable schedules than strategy work. But busy and intense periods happen everywhere in consulting when deadlines approach.

 

Travel Expectations

 

Both strategy and management consulting traditionally involved heavy travel. The classic model was flying to the client site Monday morning, flying home Thursday night, and working from the home office on Friday.

 

COVID changed this significantly. Many projects now run partially or fully remote. But travel hasn't disappeared. Strategy projects often require less on-site time than implementation work, since you're not embedded with the client's operational teams.

 

Exit Opportunities

 

Where you can go after consulting depends partly on what type of consulting you did. Both open doors to lots of opportunities.

 

Strategy Consulting Exits

 

Strategy consultants from MBB firms have the widest range of exit options. Corporate strategy roles at Fortune 500 companies actively recruit from these firms. So do private equity and venture capital firms, which value the analytical skills and business judgment developed in strategy work.

 

Many MBB alumni eventually reach C-suite positions. The combination of structured problem solving, executive communication skills, and exposure to diverse industries prepares people for general management roles.

 

Common exits include:

 

  • Head of corporate strategy
  • Chief of staff to CEO
  • Private equity associate
  • Venture capital roles
  • Startup leadership
  • Operational roles at portfolio companies

 

Management Consulting Exits

 

Management consultants often exit into functional roles related to their consulting specialty. If you spent three years implementing supply chain transformations, you're well positioned for VP of Supply Chain roles. Technology consultants move into CTO or CIO positions. Operations consultants become COOs.

 

The Big Four consulting practices also feed heavily into industry roles. Many companies hire Big Four alumni into finance, risk, and technology leadership positions. The path to C-suite exists, but it often runs through functional leadership rather than corporate strategy.

 

Why Strategy Consulting Is Often Called the Better Career Launchpad

 

Strategy consulting, particularly at MBB, is often described as the best career accelerator available. The brand recognition opens doors. The skills transfer broadly. The alumni networks are powerful.

 

If you're uncertain about your long-term career direction, strategy consulting keeps more options open than specialized management consulting.

 

That said, if you know you want to become a CTO or run operations at a manufacturing company, specialized management consulting experience might actually be more relevant than pure strategy work.

 

Which Is Right for You?

 

Choosing between strategy and management consulting depends on your interests, strengths, and career goals. Here's a framework for thinking through the decision.

 

Consider Strategy Consulting If:

 

  • You enjoy big-picture thinking over detailed execution
  • You thrive in ambiguous situations where there's no clear right answer
  • You want maximum optionality for future career moves
  • You're interested in private equity or corporate strategy roles
  • You want to work directly with C-suite executives early in your career
  • Compensation is a top priority

 

Consider Management Consulting If:

 

  • You prefer seeing your recommendations actually implemented
  • You want to develop deep expertise in a specific domain (technology, operations, etc.)
  • You're interested in functional leadership roles like CTO, COO, or VP of Operations
  • You prefer more structured problems with clearer paths to solutions
  • You value slightly better work-life balance (though this varies)
  • You want to work at a Big Four firm for the brand and breadth of services

 

Questions to Ask Yourself

 

  • Do I prefer asking "what should we do?" or "how do we do it?"
  • Am I energized by uncertainty or frustrated by it?
  • Do I want to specialize deeply or stay generalist?
  • What do I want to be doing in 10 years?

 

Your answers will point you toward one type or the other. Neither is objectively better. They're different paths that suit different people.

 

Does It Matter for Your Job Search?

 

Here's the practical reality: the distinction between strategy and management consulting matters less for your job search than you might think.

 

Most Firms Hire Generalists

 

At both MBB and Big Four, entry-level consultants are typically hired as generalists. You don't interview specifically for "strategy" versus "implementation" roles.

 

You interview for the firm, and staffing decisions happen after you join. This means you don't need to declare a specialty during recruiting.

 

The Interview Process Is Nearly Identical

 

Whether you're interviewing at McKinsey or Deloitte Consulting, you'll face case interviews. The format is the same: you're presented with a business problem and asked to work through it. 

 

Behavioral interviews also look similar across firms. Your preparation approach works for both types of consulting.

 

How to Position Yourself

 

When explaining your interest in consulting, focus on the aspects that genuinely excite you.

 

If you love solving ambiguous strategic problems, say that. If you're drawn to implementing real change in organizations, emphasize that.

 

Don't try to guess what the interviewer wants to hear. Authenticity matters because it helps you end up somewhere that actually fits you.

 

That said, know which firms focus on what. If you're interviewing at McKinsey, understand that they're known for strategy work. If you're interviewing at Accenture, understand their strength is technology and implementation. Tailor your "why this firm" answer accordingly.

 

Apply Broadly, Then Choose

 

Consulting recruiting is competitive. Most candidates apply to multiple firms across both categories. You might interview at McKinsey, BCG, Deloitte, and Accenture.

 

If you're fortunate enough to get multiple offers, you can make your choice then. Don't limit your options prematurely by deciding you only want "strategy consulting" or only want "management consulting."

 

Your Next Step to a Consulting Offer

 

Ready to stop struggling with case interviews and start landing consulting offers?

 

Enroll in my step-by-step case interview course:

 

  • Get interview-ready in 7 days, not 6–8 weeks

 

  • Create perfect frameworks in under 60 seconds

 

  • Build business acumen in 2 hours, not 2 years

 

  • Solve case math 2x faster with 80% fewer errors

 

  • Practice with 20 cases covering 95% of case types

 

Join 3,000+ candidates who've landed offers at McKinsey, BCG, Bain, and other top firms. 82% of my students land consulting offers.
 
👉 Enroll Now